العربية
Breaking

How Does the Open-Book Exam Affect Assessment Fairness in High School Tests?

 

Between Dream and Reality: An Analytical Study of the Impact of the Open-Book Exam System on Assessment Fairness in Egypt’s Thanaweya Amma (High School) Exams from 2019 to 2024

Prepared by: Prof. Osama Maher Hussein, Professor of Educational Planning and Foundations, National Center for Examinations and Educational Evaluation, Cairo.

Introduction: In an era marked by rapid developments in knowledge and technology, it has become necessary to rethink educational assessment methods to keep pace with these changes. The open-book exam system is one such approach implemented in Egypt’s Thanaweya Amma exams to improve educational assessment and foster critical thinking skills and deep understanding among students.

The study aimed to evaluate the open-book exam experience in Egypt’s Thanaweya Amma exams, analyze the extent to which the system achieves assessment fairness, identify implementation challenges, and offer recommendations for improvement.

The researcher outlined the standards expected in an open-book test when applied to high school students, and addressed critical questions raised about the system by specialized public opinion, answering them in light of the researcher’s expertise in measurement and evaluation. In addition, the researcher presented and analyzed the reactions of students, teachers, and experts regarding the open-book exam system, drawing on reliable public opinion polls that captured feedback from educational experts, teachers, students, and parents in general secondary education. The results showed a divergence of views. While some believe the system promotes deep understanding and reduces exam stress, others pointed to challenges related to preparation and training for this new exam style. Furthermore, the study showed that the system requires students to have a deep understanding of the subject matter and high analytical abilities, which are difficult to achieve without proper infrastructure preparation and the necessary training for teachers and students.

In addition, the researcher presented and analyzed the psychological and social impacts and dimensions of the open-book exam on both students and teachers in Thanaweya Amma. International and regional experiences in using open-book testing in pre-university and university education were then reviewed, examining 15 such experiences to understand their objectives, implementation mechanisms, and the optimal model chosen from the various types and formats of open-book tests.

The study reached several important conclusions, summarized in the following points:

1. Assessment Fairness: The open-book system achieved a level of fairness in evaluation by reducing individual differences among students, though it still faces challenges related to preparation and practical implementation.

2. Critical Understanding: The system helped improve students’ level of critical understanding, but it requires continuous curriculum development and intensive teacher training.

3. Implementation Challenges: The most prominent challenges included a lack of necessary infrastructure, insufficient training for teachers and students, and the phenomena of cheating and leaks, which affect fairness in evaluation.

The study outlined a set of recommendations and proposals directed to educational decision-makers in the Ministry of Education and the heads of education committees in legislative bodies, which include:

• Conducting a comprehensive evaluation study including (evaluating the costs and benefits of the system, analyzing academic performance)

• Improving infrastructure and technology: (developing digital infrastructure, providing digital educational resources).

• Developing comprehensive training programs: (training teachers and supervisors in question formulation, enhancing administrative capacities)

• Enhancing transparency and accountability: (periodic evaluation of results, engaging the educational community).

• An alternative strategy to improve the educational system: (relying on diverse assessment methods, promoting project-based learning).

• Evaluating and enhancing the accuracy and quality of question banks: (analyzing and correcting errors, updating question banks periodically).

• Improving the printing quality and distribution of exams.

• Conducting field trials for questions.

• Analyzing exam results.

• Ensuring adequate and fair time allocation for answering questions through:

✓ Accurately evaluating the time allocated for answers: Ensuring that the time allotted for answering questions is standardized and has been tested to ensure fairness.

✓ Conducting trial tests: Implementing test runs to ensure that the allotted time is sufficient for answering without stress.

✓ Combating cheating: Enhancing anti-cheating measures to ensure that the time allocated for answers reflects its true impact on the performance of hardworking students.

✓ Providing psychological support: Offering psychological support and guidance to students on how to manage time during the exam to reduce stress and increase focus

In conclusion, the study confirmed that the open-book exam system is an important step toward developing Egypt’s education system, though it needs further support and improvement, as well as selection of the most suitable model to fully achieve its educational objectives.

https://online.fliphtml5.com/zpcch/atux/

Want a website as good as Ahram Scientific Magazine? Order your website design now via WhatsApp
How Does the Open-Book Exam Affect Assessment Fairness in High School Tests?
Published by Hany Sallam

Hany Sallam, Founder and Editor-in-Chief of Scientific Magazine Ahram
An independent Arabic science magazine operating since 2008, dedicated to simplifying science, technology, space, natural phenomena and scientific stories for Arabic readers. The magazine includes sections such as “Zodiac Group” and “Stories and Tales”, alongside science topics that combine knowledge with a spirit of discovery. It operates independently and is not affiliated with Al-Ahram Press Foundation or any governmental body.

Leave a Comment

Prove you are human: 1   +   1   =  

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Saved articles