العربية
Breaking

The Exam Paper: Between Specifications and Relative Weight, Painful Reality and Desired Hope (1)

The Exam Paper

Between Its Specifications and Relative Weight

The Painful Reality and the Desired Hope

( 1 )

 

Every family aspires to educate its children at the highest level, no matter the burden this places on them, and every family pushes its children to make this dream a reality. To achieve this dream, no mother or father spares any effort for their children. Many students work hard through private lessons, educational platforms, tutoring centers, and our school channel, while very few rely on the school itself! This is another matter that will be addressed in a series of articles on administrative reform.

Amid the hard work of students and their teachers, and the effort to provide all expenses to achieve this dream, comes that one thing which may make the dream come true, kill it, or wound it: the exam… assessment… measurement… call it what you will, and this is the crux of the matter.

The exam—the common name for assessment, measurement, or testing—is a fundamental condition and an important requirement at most educational stages. It serves to announce the completion of a stage and entry into the next, or to crown pre-university education with a test that concludes an entire educational stage so students can begin a new one that may differ significantly or somewhat from the previous one.

This means that the exam (whatever it may be called) must have rules and specifications that make it a measurement producing genuine differentiation among students. It should distinguish between high-achieving, average, and weak students, while at the same time rewarding hardworking students for their efforts without frustrating them with impossible questions or material from outside the curriculum.

The question here is: Is this actually what happens in our education? Is the exam (assessment, test, measurement) truly a successful standard for judging students? Leaving aside all the questions that jump to our minds, let us go straight to a very important question: Is there a binding rule for the test so that we can point to it as a measurement that evaluates and judges our students fairly?

Indeed, there is a rule—we might call it a rule—which is the relative weight of the subject.

However, before addressing the relative weight of the subject and the specifications of the exam paper, we need to address some important definitions and terms that clarify and lay the groundwork for the concepts of exam paper specifications and subject relative weight.

Important Definitions:

Assessment – Thanaweya Amma (High School Diploma) certificate – Content analysis – Modern Bloom’s taxonomy.

 

Assessment: An innate human process that may be spontaneous or organized and systematic. In our educational system, assessment takes place solely through testing.

Assessment has foundations, and we cannot call something an assessment unless it is built upon four pillars:

Comprehensiveness, continuity, diversification, and objectivity.

Measurement:

An organized process used to determine the magnitude of a specific characteristic in something, expressed in terms of an appropriate unit of measurement.

Measurement in the Educational Process:

It is the measurement of student achievement of planned objectives through achievement tests and the mastery of continuous assessment skills, which fulfill cognitive achievement and the skills acquired by students.

 

A – What Is the Thanaweya Amma Certificate?

 

The Thanaweya Amma certificate is defined as the final stage of school education. Its examinations are conducted centrally at the national level, and obtaining this certificate requires passing tests in a group of core and specialized subjects, which vary according to the academic track chosen by the student (scientific or literary).

The results of these exams are factors in determining students’ academic and professional futures, as admission decisions for various universities and colleges are based on them. It is an educational certificate that students receive after successfully completing the secondary stage.

Definition of Content

 

It is a collection of (information, principles, concepts, ideas, accompanied by images, drawings, diagrams, questions, and applications) presented in a context that includes information that needs to be taught to students.

B – The Concept of Study Content Analysis.

 

It is: tallying the basic knowledge and skills included in the lessons and writing them down. Content analysis is carried out according to a specific classification of knowledge, which consists of: (facts, concepts, generalizations, scientific laws, scientific theories).

By “according to a specific classification of knowledge,” we mean Bloom’s taxonomy, whether old or modern. Therefore, we need to address both the old and modern viewpoints of Bloom.

Bloom’s Old Pyramid: A Traditional Approach

Traditional Bloom’s taxonomy, established in the 1950s, consists of a pyramid with six hierarchical levels: knowledge, comprehension, application, analysis, synthesis, and evaluation. This model aims to guide and direct teachers regarding the creation of learning objectives and effective assessments.

One of the key characteristics of the old taxonomy was its focus on recall and basic understanding, with teachers concentrating on assessing students’ ability to remember facts and concepts, often through rote memorization.

 

 

Bloom’s Modern Pyramid: The Revised Bloom’s Taxonomy:

As for modern Bloom’s taxonomy, which took shape in the 21st century, it reshapes the traditional pyramid into a more dynamic and interconnected model. This revised version involves a shift from a hierarchical structure to a more flexible structure in cognitive processes.

One of the notable changes in Bloom’s taxonomy was the shift to action verbs instead of nouns, resulting in the new categories: understanding, applying, analyzing, evaluating, and creating (innovating).

In the old pyramid, evaluation was the highest skill, but the new pyramid adds innovation as the top level of the taxonomy. This indicates that innovation is the most complex cognitive skill and the highest form of learning.

The modern pyramid seeks to integrate innovation with critical thinking, focusing more strongly on higher-order thinking skills, including innovation, critical thinking, and problem-solving. It guides teachers to design activities and assessments that prompt students to apply theoretical knowledge in practical scenarios.

Dear reader… You may grow weary of the theoretical framework, concepts, and definitions, but this is important so that we understand and conclude that the exam—specifically the high school final exam—is fair and truly measures what it was designed for, as people say and as we hope.

This prompts us to address the subject in a scientific and straightforward manner to clarify the actual reality of exams and how to achieve their purpose of truly measuring students by applying a scientific system grounded in scientific concepts, rather than what is said or rumored about flexing muscles on students.

Moving on to the second article… Examinations and tests in Egyptian education in light of the concept of content analysis and relative weight.

 

Mohamed Mostafa El-Gezawy

Consultant of Public Education General Administration

Former General Director of Public Education

Former General Director of Borg El Arab Administration

 

 

 

Want a website as good as Ahram Scientific Magazine? Order your website design now via WhatsApp
The Exam Paper: Between Specifications and Relative Weight, Painful Reality and Desired Hope (1)
Published by Hany Sallam

Hany Sallam, Founder and Editor-in-Chief of Scientific Magazine Ahram
An independent Arabic science magazine operating since 2008, dedicated to simplifying science, technology, space, natural phenomena and scientific stories for Arabic readers. The magazine includes sections such as “Zodiac Group” and “Stories and Tales”, alongside science topics that combine knowledge with a spirit of discovery. It operates independently and is not affiliated with Al-Ahram Press Foundation or any governmental body.

Leave a Comment

Prove you are human: 5   +   5   =  

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Saved articles