Administrative Reform 2
The Minister Between the Demands of the Presidential Statement
And the Draft Law on the National Council for Education
(An incidental article prompted by the resignation of the cabinet)
Finally, the presidential statement, awaited for two months, arrived to announce the resignation of the cabinet headed by Prime Minister Dr. Mostafa Madbouly. The statement specified—and pay close attention to this—that a new cabinet must be formed of individuals with high competencies, expertise, and distinguished capabilities, tasked with achieving a number of goals, foremost among them… particularly in the fields of health and education… and so on through the rest of the presidential mandate.
Anyone following this presidential statement will find, with a little focus, a completely clear indication from the President of the need for individuals with actual expertise documented by practical experience, rather than mere loyalists burdened with bloated photo portfolios. Continuing to read the statement, we find specific mandates for health and education—and what can be said about health and education!
At the same time, or just before the cabinet resignation and the presidential statement, the Prime Minister’s office approved a draft law to establish the National Council for Education, a body that reports directly to the President. If one connects the National Council for Education with the presidential statement, several points emerge:
- As we mentioned, the presidential statement spoke clearly and firmly about the need for experts endowed with competencies, expertise, and exceptional capabilities. This means the minister chosen must possess these qualities to achieve the assigned goal in the state’s plan, in accordance with the presidential statement.
- When looking at the draft law of the National Council for Education and the Council’s jurisdictions under the draft law, we find first that anyone who imagines the role of the minister—whether returning or newly appointed—is merely to execute policies is entirely mistaken. A review of the role of the National Council for Education shows that it will set general policies for education of all types and at all stages, achieve integration among them, and supervise their implementation, with the aim of advancing education and developing its outputs to match the requirements of the local and international labor markets. It also aims to formulate general policies for research and innovation. Consequently, the minister’s role is not just policy execution, but playing a principal part in formulating policy and then executing it. Thus, the minister’s role has grown significantly larger than before, especially since details will be submitted to the head of state through a detailed report every six months.
- To achieve its goals, the Council is tasked with establishing the national strategy, plans, and programs for developing education, research, and innovation, along with mechanisms to monitor their implementation in coordination with relevant ministries, bodies, and agencies. It also reviews and updates national priorities in education, research, and innovation across various sectors, and prepares recommendations concerning the technical, administrative, legal, and economic frameworks needed to develop the work system and achieve state targets. This requires the minister—whether returning or newly appointed—to effect a comprehensive change in the administrative system specifically within the Ministry of Education, review all related entities, and reshape their objectives and roles in light of the National Council for Education and its jurisdictions.
- The Council is tasked with developing the organizational structures of the institutions responsible for implementing the educational process (pre-university and university), as well as developing operating systems and coordination channels that ensure the efficient achievement of planned objectives, alongside establishing rules and mechanisms to guarantee the proper selection of officials responsible for the educational process (pre-university and university) and those responsible for the research and innovation system, in light of scientific and administrative competence… This means the minister—returning or newly appointed—faces no easy task. Developing the organizational structures of the educational institution requires, as we said, radical treatment and surgery for longstanding entities that are outdated or no longer achieve their desired purpose in light of what is termed the New Republic. Not only that, but the minister must also contribute to and execute the selection of officials for the educational process. Accordingly, we will no longer see loyalists or individuals tasked with special assignments who are entrusted with carrying out the minister’s instructions—formerly known as the minister’s men, the senior committee men, kings of photo ops and promotional displays, and so forth. Add to this that the minister will personally submit a clear report on their selections. This will require the minister—whether returning or newly appointed—to fully commit to clear selection criteria where being merely trusted is not enough; they must also possess opinion and thought, and devise strong, out-of-the-box solutions to resolve the historical problems facing education in Egypt.
Without dwelling too long on the National Education Council draft law and the presidential statement on the cabinet formation—since the focus here is education—the logical question is: What do we expect from the minister, whether returning or new? Will the chosen minister fix the flaws in society’s most vital sector, which is education in all its components, or at least begin to address the educational problems facing society? These range from teachers, abandoned schools, and the spread of private tutoring, to the arbitrary selection of leaders, the unfair distribution of financial allocations among education workers, and the ultimate problem: the general secondary certificate and its assessment system. There are also the entities linked to the ministry, such as the National Center for Educational Examination and Evaluation, the Professional Academy for Teachers, and the Center for Curriculum Development, along with various internal entities that have been restructured without us seeing any tangible impact on the ground. The ministry submitted a restructuring proposal to the Central Agency for Organization and Administration, but it was not handled properly. What, then, of the newly created sectors where some close associates or loyalists have been placed?
I return to the responsibility resting on the minister, whether returning or new, in accordance with the demands of the presidential statement. As a former executive official, I have questions—and others may have more and deeper ones:
- How will the directorates of education in the governorates be handled, how will evaluations be conducted according to specific, transparently announced criteria, and will those at fault be held accountable?
- Will the financial accountability of the boards of trustees over past years be disclosed, and will a new law or ministerial decree be established for these boards, which over past years have offered nothing new and have not been held financially accountable, despite many having reservations about spending practices?
- When will the hidden curriculum for the first year of preparatory school be revealed, when will teachers be trained on it, and will this be done over a sufficient period or, as usual, just a few days?
- What is the fate of the second foreign language in the first year of preparatory school, and how will we address the shortage of second-language teachers in French, Italian, and others, given that there will be no instructions to appoint staff in this category and there is already a shortage of these subjects in secondary schools? Or will the idea be “you study on your own, and we will test you”?
- How will new schools be handled, and where will the teachers come from to operate them when we have a glaring shortage?
- What about official language schools, the proficiency level of their teachers, and the training programs from a few years ago intended to raise their competence?
- The general secondary certificate is a ticking time bomb in most Egyptian homes. Will there be an actual evaluation of it? Will the vision of Professor Dr. Tarek Shawki be implemented—a vision that resulted in nothing other than changing the format of the exam, often turning it into a riddle or puzzle, flexing muscles in a number of math, chemistry, physics, history, and other exams, and strangely failing to specify the exam paper blueprint on the ministry’s page (see our article on the exam paper specifications and the first and second relative weights)—along with other raised points concerning the third year of secondary school?
- Most importantly, can the minister develop an investment plan for education? We previously presented a simple conceptual vision for funding education and how to invest in education for the benefit of education.
Many who care about education and work within it can add numerous questions, and many count on the minister to find practical solutions for them.
Although this article came about incidentally due to the topical issue of the anticipated cabinet reshuffle, it can also be classified among administrative reform articles, which—God willing—will be continued immediately. As I have said before, these articles, visions, or proposals are not for those who are chosen for their loyalty or those who nod along to keep their seats; rather, they are for those to whom we say: Peace be upon those who spoke the truth even if it hurt, and who exhorted one another to patience even if it exhausted them.
Mohamed Mostafa Mohamed Hussein El-Gezawy
Consultant in Public Education Management
Former General Director of General Education
Former General Director of Borg El Arab Educational Administration


Latest video
تابع معنا تحليل قراءة الصحف اليومية مع الكاتب الصحفي Hany Sallam عبر