
The 2024 physics exam, preceded by the Arabic language exam earlier the same year—and God alone knows what unimaginable difficulties may emerge in this year’s remaining tests—finds students enduring power cuts and soaring temperatures, alongside the difficulty of bringing in fans despite whatever official statements and troubles have been reported, not to mention the unjustified time wasted on student sign-ins. On top of all this came an extreme and unjustified difficulty in the physics exam. Moving past the complete departure from exam paper specifications and the preparation of achievement tests (refer to my previous articles on the exam and how it was set), the Ministry issued the following decisions in the wake of the physics exam fiasco:
1. Preparing a report by an independent technical committee on whether the physics exam question paper and answer key met the specifications, assuring that no student will be harmed during grading.
2. The Minister extending reassuring messages to all students while issuing directives to a specialized, independent technical committee to rapidly prepare its report on whether the question paper and answer key met specifications, and to ensure there were no flawed questions or multiple-choice questions with more than one plausible answer.
3. The Minister is closely monitoring the technical committee’s report, student interests will be put at the top of priorities, and no student will be harmed during grading.
Accordingly, this is the awaited committee. But just as no one knew anything about the criteria for selecting the exam setters, or how they were chosen, and just as we still do not know the real role of the National Center for Examinations and Educational Evaluation located in Mokattam—which we will discuss another time—we will know nothing about this technical committee except that it is independent! Feel free to add hundreds of exclamation and question marks regarding the concept and meaning of “independent,” and whether the committee’s members will be announced. The important question is: what can we, as education stakeholders and officials, and what can parents expect from this task?
Generally speaking, if I were responsible for this “independent” committee, I would draw up the following work plan:
1. Determine whether the time allocated was appropriate for students to solve the paper in its current state—meaning taking the exam as it was, with all reported typographical and technical errors—keeping in mind that the abilities of the “independent” committee members differ completely from those of the students.
2. Review the physics exam linguistically across both the Arabic and translated versions, identify questions containing errors that made it impossible for students to answer, exclude them entirely, and award full marks to the students.
3. Review the multiple-choice and essay questions and check them against the specifications—noting that no specifications have been published other than those stated by the Minister, who set 30 percent of the questions for higher-order thinking skills, a point the Minister of Education emphasized should follow the National Center’s specifications. However, the official spokesperson for the Ministry of Education asserted that the general secondary exam specifications are 30 percent for basic cognitive levels, 40 percent for intermediate levels, and 30 percent for higher levels! Although we disagree with the notion that these general specifications are precise, the “independent” committee can review each question against these standards and determine whether the exam matched the announced percentages.
4. Once the committee identifies the questions agreed to match the percentages announced by the ministry (the published specifications), it should draw a 10 percent sample of actual student grading for each question. This will reveal 25 percent of the exam’s true difficulty or ease, reflecting the actual reality on the ground.
5. The “independent” committee should present its findings to the competent authority, including a report on whether the exam matched the specifications announced by the Minister—meaning 70 percent of the questions were at the level of the average student, as the Minister stated—or otherwise, and publish the results of this “independent” committee with complete transparency and clarity.
One observation worth noting is that questions containing typographical or technical errors—such as the famous weight question where weight 1 or 2 was mentioned, but no numbers appeared in the diagram to clarify which was weight 1 or 2—along with translation errors between the Arabic and other language versions, must either be awarded full marks or removed, with their marks redistributed across the remaining questions.
This is a proposal to remedy a flawed and even unfair situation for general secondary students in this year’s 2024 physics exam. Some may view this proposal as not fast enough, but it needs only one week of work from the neutral committee, especially given how easy electronic grading of student papers is. In fact, this would provide students with a sense of reassurance to compensate for what happened on that bloody Saturday. Perhaps the ministry will wake up and look at the remaining exams so we do not see surprises from the question setters or the question bank, as the ministry likes to convince others that the exams come from the question bank! We return once again to the starting point and the endless circle of the question bank with its secret paths—known to no one except the National Center for Examinations and Educational Evaluation located in Mokattam—how questions are chosen from the question bank by whom, and many other questions that can be discussed in the future.
Mohamed Mostafa El-Gezeiry
Consultant of Public Education General Administration
Former General Director of Public Education
Former General Director of Borg El Arab Administration


Latest video
تابع معنا تحليل قراءة الصحف اليومية مع الكاتب الصحفي Hany Sallam عبر