A Vision… For a Vision (Articles on Education)
-1-
Legitimate Questions Regarding the Minister’s Vision
Introduction:
• To begin with, this is a reformative, critical vision, rather than a purely critical one as is my usual approach when writing about the reality of education.
• Baccalaureate—the term given to the minister’s new project—bears no connection whatsoever, whether close or remote, to the name of the old baccalaureate; the difference between the two is vast.
• The new senior secondary system (the Baccalaureate) may at first glance seem to be a derivation or Arabization of the International Baccalaureate or the English diploma, but anyone who examines and compares the two according to what has been announced about the Egyptian Baccalaureate will find a very large difference between them, at least from my point of view.
• Education… the importance of learning, folks! Borrowing from the common phrase “the importance of getting cultured, folks,” it is no longer just about the importance of learning, folks, but rather about how education will be activated and utilized in practical life and to serve the nation.
• The actual and true target is the student, because the student is the foundation for all educational development processes. If you want to bring about change, development, or a new invention, the student must be your goal, while everything else consists of supporting factors that help bring about change and development, assisting this student from childhood through adolescence to face not only local society, but external society as well.
• In our educational system… we have students to whom an educational program called 2.0 has been applied, spanning from kindergarten to the first year of preparatory school; students in the second and third years of preparatory school, who are on an old educational system; then high school students, to whom a completely new system was applied at the beginning of this year, differing from what was implemented and dealt with in the high school stage; and finally, third-year secondary students who did not take last year’s exam at all in all subjects, along with students failing some subjects, and students who postponed some subjects?! (Not an easy problem).
• The culture of change, the timing of change, and addressing most of the factors that hinder change are studies and a science whose techniques any leadership intending to bring about change must master, especially in the field of education. This comes alongside sudden, sharp shifts—from textbooks and traditional methods used for years to tablets, networks, electronic exams, smartboards, networks, and a system called 2.0, to strange outcries about the return of traditional village schools (kuttab) and the sudden modification of the senior secondary system just before the start of the 2024/2025 academic year, and before the educational system, parents, and education stakeholders could recover from comprehending this sudden change. (A side note: within a span of no more than 10 years, the Ministry of Education has seen four successive ministers, each with a completely different vision and strategy, regardless of what has been said about implementing a unified strategy—which is a major mistake). Everyone was then surprised, after a very large number of amendments to curricula, assessment systems, and reports, by a decision resembling a radical overhaul and comprehensive transformation of the senior secondary stage system!!!
Here we pause briefly—though we do not stay silent, neither a little nor a lot, as the saying goes—then resume our walk and discussion in more than one direction, noting that this is neither a rejection nor an approval of the project itself, but rather an clarification of the idea and a discussion of its dimensions:
Direction One: Numerous questions must have swept through the minds of many education stakeholders—meaning experts, teachers, parents, students, and others—and they must be answered, or at least most of them, so that everyone or the majority can accept the new system and participate in it?!
Direction Two: A discussion of the contents of the new system in all its dimensions, as included in the minister’s new system called the Baccalaureate, starting with the description of subjects across the three years, whether this aligns with international data and the demands of the age amid unprecedented scientific explosion, and whether there are other proposals and modifications to this model.
Direction Three: How to implement the Minister of Education’s vision in reality and within the educational climate, address existing difficulties and problems—specifically teacher shortages, curricula, the administrative system in the ministry’s headquarters and educational directorates—and handle teacher training and the assessment system.
Direction One:
Without a doubt, many questions must have run through everyone’s heads and severely weighed on their minds. Perhaps the first things to cross the minds and thoughts of many are legitimate questions to which everyone has a right:
1 – Was changing the senior secondary system—whatever the name, whether general secondary or baccalaureate—on the table when the Egypt 2030 document was written, given that it was the governing document established as our working strategy, against which the extent of implementation for everything in the 2030 document is measured? The answer is no!!!
2 – Why was the structure of the secondary stage reorganized at the start of this 2024–2025 academic year in a sudden manner, given that the entire general secondary system will change next year according to what was announced?
3 – Where is the study that was conducted to produce this proposed system? And where is the voice of education experts regarding these decisions? Or is it a personal vision?
4 – Why, in the new system, are some curricula called “advanced level”? Is this due to quantity or quality?
5 – Why do we study congested curricula when we can split the curriculum across the second and third grades?
6 – Where are these curricula, and have they been prepared or are they still on the drawing board, especially since the Curriculum Development Center—according to many studies, opinion polls, and the views of specialists and stakeholders—needs to be reviewed and developed?
7 – For two years, there was what the President of the Republic called the “National Dialogue,” during which he gave a recommendation to discuss all topics related to the nation, including freedoms, the economy, health, education, and so on. Was the topic of changing the Thanawiya Amma discussed in this manner, given that there were discussions concerning education attended by a number of educational experts, led by former minister Dr. Reda Hegazy and a number of ministry officials, as well as experts from faculties of education?
8 – The incomprehensible and scientifically and educationally unjustified disappearance and reappearance of school subjects is striking. For example, religious education disappears in the second year of secondary school, then reappears to become a core subject in the critical third year. Those who justify this claim that the second and third years have become complementary to each other; so why did this not apply to the remaining three subjects: Arabic, a foreign language, and history? Is it wise for religious education to be given 100 marks, and if added to the total score, to equal the marks of specialized subjects?! It is illogical, and there are many justifications for this specific question that could lead us into comparisons that we—the people of Egypt—can do without. I do not know if the architects of the new system are aware that there is only a single consultant for Islamic and Christian religious education in the ministry, and that personally, I went through a bitter experience—which I see no need to recount here, at least regarding this topic—aimed at reforming the administrative system for Islamic and Christian religious education.
9 – Where is the sequential structure of the curriculum? Let us look back many years to the era of Professor Dr. Hussein Kamel Bahaa El-Din and the standards system, which was developed through a very large team of educational experts, the local community, and education stakeholders. After numerous reviews, discussions, and meetings, the standards document emerged, a large part of which was dedicated to the curriculum framework. Similarly, in the English education system, after conferences and input from educational experts, the standards document for the English curriculum emerged, known as the National Curriculum, which features logical and sequential arrangements for the curriculum. To take a simple example: you cannot go to the second floor without having built the ground and first floors. A child cannot learn addition without knowing and grasping the concept of numbers and the operation of addition. Therefore, the so-called sequential curriculum standards for each subject must be presented, starting from kindergarten and running through to the end of secondary school.
10 – It is axiomatic, according to what we learned from our professors in education, that publishing a theory or a scientific thesis involves reviewing or presenting it to specialists for feedback. Here is an important question: was there a major scientific conference where the reform of the Thanawiya Amma system was discussed, attended by educational experts, various professors from faculties of education, and education stakeholders, resulting in recommendations that illuminate the path for the decision to change Thanawiya Amma and rename it the baccalaureate?
11 – The most important and serious question, in my view: there is a National Council for Education established by Presidential Decree No. 163 of 2024 on December 8, 2024, whose primary duties under the first item include formulating the national strategy, plans, and programs for developing education, research, and innovation. Since the Thanawiya Amma stage is an educational phase, was this project or the new system presented to the council in all its dimensions? The discussion here concerns decision-making itself rather than technical details, as those require a separate discussion.
12 – The next most important question: for the minister’s project and vision to be implemented, it must be approved by the House of Representatives, and prior to that, the Senate. Both must present it to the local community, and extensive community discussions should take place with parents, educational centers, specialists, and even the Supreme Council of Universities, since it will receive this product. Will the product match university standards? This means that rushing implementation next year needs to be reviewed in accordance with the constitution and logic.
Does all this brainstorming and the subsequent questions mean there is rejection of this system announced by the minister?
Certainly, whoever thinks that is entirely mistaken and fails to recognize the supreme value of discussion and dialogue, which we and many successful leaders have learned and already practice, out of confidence that discussion and critique—accompanied by better solutions—are far superior to blind obedience and ignoring actual realities and their requirements.
At the end of this first part of the dialogue, we should have the philosophical vision—speaking of philosophy, which has been ignored along with psychology—that we learned from our distinguished professors in management and education: choosing the timing of decisions directed at public opinion is crucial, ensuring they align and run parallel with the majority of the local community after discussing the decisions with them and acquainting them with their inner workings, so that the public becomes the primary line of defense for these decisions.
To conclude this first article: implementing decisions without listening to the views of education experts in Egypt will lead to long-term problems that cannot be fixed. Without clarifying matters to the public and the local community and imposing decisions upon them, this change will be of no use, even if it is mandatory.
There is more to discuss, God willing.
Mohamed Mostafa El-Gezawy
Public Education Management Consultant
Former General Director of Public Education
Former General Director of Borg El Arab Administration
This article is exclusive to Ahram Science Magazine, and neither the article nor any part of it may be copied or published except with written permission from the Board of Directors of Ahram Science Magazine.


Latest video
تابع معنا تحليل قراءة الصحف اليومية مع الكاتب الصحفي Hany Sallam عبر