A Vision… for Vision (Articles on Education)
2
The Minister’s Proposal… Between Pros and Cons
Part One
Note: The second article is in two parts.
Introduction:
• To begin with—as repetition brings benefit—this is a reformist critical vision, not merely a critical one as is my usual approach when writing about the reality of education.
• The baccalaureate—to reiterate for benefit—is the term given to the new minister’s project, and it has no connection whatsoever, near or far, to the old baccalaureate name; the difference between them is vast.
• This proposal put forward by the Minister of Education and Technical Education can be the cornerstone for moving the educational system to a position and level that rivals some advanced Arab countries, provided that development is comprehensive and not merely a superficial change, as we will discuss in detail. Otherwise—in my personal view—it is a hasty attempt that will not bear its intended fruit.
• Some statistics:
– The number of general secondary students last year reached 729,835, including 323,174 male students and 406,661 female students. This number doubles when adding second-year secondary students according to the ministry’s new vision (and this is an important note that must be taken into account, as will be clarified later).
– Egyptian family spending on education varies according to income level; the lowest-income bracket spends 6.4%, while the highest-income bracket spends 18.9% (this must also be taken into account, especially when applying the new vision and calculating the cost of retaking an exam for improvement purposes).
– Spending on private tutoring and support groups accounts for 30.8% of the lowest-income bracket’s spending on education, while this percentage reaches 67.1% for the highest-income bracket, according to the Income and Expenditure Survey issued by the Central Agency for Public Mobilization and Statistics for 2019–2020 (noting that these data do not cover spending levels after the corona pandemic and the economic crisis Egypt has been experiencing since 2022).
• The general secondary stage has always been targeted for change by a number of ministers. For example: in 1994, a two-stage system was applied with mandatory and elective subjects in what was known as the improvement system, then in 1996 the total score improvement system was cancelled! In 2013, general secondary returned to a single year (completely cancelling the improvement system and what was known as the Hussein Kamel Bahaa El-Din amendment) and became three tracks. In 2017, the booklet system was introduced following the famous exam leak incident to prevent cheating, then the entire system was modified during the tenure of Prof. Tarek Shawky, introducing the tablet system while keeping general secondary exams on paper using multiple-choice questions known as the bubble sheet. Then, during the tenure of Prof. Reda Hegazy, some very simple essay questions were added to the general secondary exam, and last but not least, this year’s comprehensive and sudden change to the general secondary stage as a whole less than a month before the start of the academic year!.
• If the new system—dubbed the baccalaureate—is implemented, the Egyptian baccalaureate will not apply to students in international schools, the Nile Egyptian Schools, or the International Public Schools (IPS).
This is an introduction that was necessary to clarify certain data points that must be considered when discussing the new minister’s vision. We note that the dialogue revolves around three dimensions:
The first: numerous questions must have raced through the minds of many educational stakeholders—meaning experts, teachers, parents, students, and others—and these questions must be answered, or at least most of them, so that everyone or the majority can accept the new system and participate in it? This has been addressed.
The second dimension: discussing the contents of the new system across all dimensions included in the minister’s new system called the baccalaureate, starting with the description of subjects over the three years, whether this aligns with international data and contemporary requirements amid the unprecedented scientific explosion, and whether there are other proposals and modifications to this model?
Second Dimension
First: The Philosophy of the New System:
According to what was announced by the Ministry of Education, the philosophy varies to include:
– Developing intellectual and critical skills as an alternative to rote memorization.
– Interdisciplinary learning by integrating scientific, literary, and artistic subjects.
– Continuous assessment and dividing subjects over at least two years.
– Multiple opportunities through two exam sessions annually.
– International recognition.
Second: Prescribed Subjects, Tracks, and Examination System:
A – First-Year Secondary Subjects:
Number Subject Name Classification
1 Religious Education Core
2 Arabic Language Core
3 English Language Core
4 Mathematics Core
5 Philosophy and Logic Core
6 Egyptian History Core
7 Integrated Sciences Core
8 Programming and Computer Science Non-core (excluded from total score)
9 Second Language Non-core (excluded from total score)
The first year of secondary school will include seven core subjects in addition to non-core subjects as shown in the table:
Track Details in the Second and Third Years of Secondary School:
The subjects studied in the second and third years will be divided into several tracks:
Track Second Year Third Year
Medicine and Life Sciences Track Arabic Language
English Language
Egyptian History
Mathematics or Physics Religious Education
Biology (Advanced Level)
Chemistry (Advanced Level)
Engineering and Computer Science Track: Arabic
English
Egyptian History
Chemistry or Programming, Religious Education
Mathematics (Advanced Level)
Physics (Advanced Level)
Business Track: Arabic
English
Egyptian History
Accounting or Business Administration, Religious Education
Economics (Advanced Level)
Mathematics
Arts and Humanities Track: Arabic
English
Egyptian History
Psychology or Second Language, Religious Education
Geography (Advanced Level)
Statistics
Examination System for Grade 11 and Grade 12 Students:
The examination system will be as follows:
Grade 11 Students:
• First attempt exam in May (free of charge).
• Second attempt exam in July for a fee of 500 pounds.
Grade 12 Students:
• First attempt exam in June (free of charge).
• Second attempt exam in August for a fee of 500 pounds.
The final total score is calculated out of 700 marks distributed across the two years, and the higher score from the two attempts is accepted.
Third: Advantages of the New Proposal (Baccalaureate): (According to the Ministry of Education statement)
– Restructuring, as the number of subjects in the general secondary education was 11 subjects in Grade 11 and Grade 12, whereas it is expected to be only 4 subjects under the baccalaureate system.
– It is supposed to reduce the pressure of private tutoring and make the student more comfortable and capable of absorbing information.
– The baccalaureate system includes new subjects related to future sciences, labor market sciences, and programming, giving the student an opportunity for creativity and future employment.
– It allows the student to choose among multiple tracks rather than just two specializations—scientific and literary—according to their inclinations and abilities, which opens up greater opportunities for them to enroll in colleges connected to each track.
– Teaching programming activities in Grade 10 to prepare students to work in the age of artificial intelligence.
– It allows the student to take the exam more than once, which relieves them of the pressure and tension felt during the traditional general secondary exams.
To be continued—Part Two
Mohamed Mostafa El-Geizawey
Consultant of Public Education Management
Former General Director of Public Education
Former General Director of Borg El Arab Administration
This article is exclusive to Ahram Science Magazine, and neither the article nor any part of it may be transferred or published except with written permission from the Board of Directors of Ahram Science Magazine


Latest video
تابع معنا تحليل قراءة الصحف اليومية مع الكاتب الصحفي Hany Sallam عبر